Talking About Race: Part III — White to White

My thanks to sapromo.com for this image.

How DO we talk about race?

That’s easy: Tentatively, cautiously, nervously. Perhaps by the end of this series, that will change.

This is dangerous, sensitive territory we’re approaching. Offense, not intended, might be taken. We don’t want to cause discomfort, we don’t want to feel tension, and so we stay silent. Yet, listen once again to Martin Luther King, Jr., in his Letter From a Birmingham Jail:

“… the great stumbling block in the stride toward freedom is … the white moderate who is more devoted to order than to justice; who prefers a negative peace, which is the absence of tension, to a positive peace, which is the presence of justice.” 

We don’t want to offend, we also don’t want to appear ignorant, or — heaven forbid — racist. However we phrase it, we don’t want to rock the boat.

So, how do we talk about race?

In October’s opening for this series, Part I, we looked at the word “race” and the idea that there is no biological basis for making distinctions based on something called race. It is the quintessential social construct, as old as the Spanish Inquisition. Race exists as a concept not because it has meaning medically (geography tells us more) or biologically, but because it has social consequences. And social origins. When we talk about “race,” we are talking about the color of a person’s skin, or the shape of a person’s facial features, — or, originally, the pureness of their blood — and the myriad assumptions that go with that distinction.

Last month, in Part II — Racism, we talked about the institutional, systemic foundation that keeps race alive as an issue — racism — and the idea that being racist can no longer be reserved for mean-spirited bigots. We looked at how we have all been caught up in the subtleties of racism, how we can’t help being “a little bit racist.” And how our focus must change from the individual “racist” — is she or isn’t she? — to the larger, systemic issue of racism and how it has not only held on so long, but grown in both depth and breadth. And continues to grow.

Today, we’re coming back to the individual: the me, the you, the I — the ones holding these conversations.

Let’s start with the recognition that racism has the ability to shape not only our experiences, but our beliefs, our values, and as a result, our choices.

One result: stories of my experience of being white, incidents I might recall where my whiteness was salient, are few.

I do have one, however: the memory of taking my best friend in high school to a youth group activity at my church. There was something about walking barefoot through cooked spaghetti; the purpose escapes me. What I do remember clearly of that experience is Linda’s response when I asked her how she’d liked my church. I wanted her to like  my church friends; I wanted us all to get along. “I was the only black person there.” I was shocked. And saddened. What did she expect! I was often the only white skin in a room in high school and it never occurred to me to complain; it was just how it was. I never asked Linda about it. I never shared with her my reaction. I never talked about it again. I never before acknowledged that in our society, it’s not only different to be the only black face among the whites, it can sometimes often be deadly.

It’s hard — if not impossible — to talk about experiences we haven’t had. Where do we start?

Someone else, someone WITH that experience must go first; then we can say, “Oh, that never happened to me.”  Linda saying she was uncomfortable being the only black person in the group upset me. And, rather than being curious, rather than trying to understand her discomfort, rather than offering her sympathy, compassion, understanding, I wrote her off as overly sensitive.

The color of my skin has always been a non-issue for me. I was taught if ever I had a question, to ask a librarian or the police (depending on the question, of course). I don’t have to worry that the color of my skin makes me suspect. I don’t have to think about it, ever; at all. As a white person in this society, I get to take a break whenever I want from caring about skin color. But I have friends who deal with racial problems daily. Some who have had to have that “talk” with their children — the one about how to behave if stopped by the police. I have friends who fear for their lives and the lives of their children only because of the color of their skin.

That I get to take a break from caring about racial issues is one example of what is meant by “white privilege.”

And it’s in recognizing and accepting this reality, I now believe, that we begin to talk about it honestly and usefully.

  Earlier this year I wrote a post for what would have been Martin Luther King’s 89th birthday. Racism: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow gave a summary of my personal history with Negroes, Coloreds, Blacks, African-Americans, People of Color, Blacks, issues of race. You can see how the problem often begins.

In that post, I included links to four reference books on white privilege.  If you’ve not yet read them, here they are again, this time not buried in a learn-more menu.

Privilege exists when one group has something of value that is denied to others simply because of the groups they belong to, rather than because of anything they’ve done or failed to do. Access to privilege doesn’t determine one’s outcomes, but it is definitely an asset that makes it more likely that whatever talent, ability, and aspirations a person with privilege has will result in something positive for them. Peggy McIntosh

So given that we want to work to create a better world in which all of us can live, what can we do? The first step, of course, is to become clear about the basics of white privilege, what it is and how it works. The second step is to explore ways in which we can work against the racism of which white privilege is a cornerstone. Francis E. Kendall

I can completely understand why broke white folks get pissed when the word ‘privilege’ is thrown around…I was constantly discriminated against because of my poverty and those wounds still run very deep…[But] The concept of intersectionality recognizes that people can be privileged in some ways and definitely not in others. ~Gina Crosley-Corcoran

White Privilege is the other side of racism. Unless we name it, we are in danger of wallowing in guilt or moral outrage with no idea of how to move beyond them. It is often easier to deplore racism and its effects than to take responsibility for the privileges some of us receive as a result of it… once we understand how white privilege operates, we can begin addressing it on an individual and institutional basis. Paula Rothenberg

How do we talk about race? I have five suggestions.

1. First of all, find your curiosity about differences. It’s there, or you wouldn’t be reading my blog.

It’s fine to appreciate the humanity we all have in common, but let’s not do that too soon. Yes indeed, there is but one race and it IS the human race, but let’s also acknowledge how being “white” in America has given us a particular frame of reference. Let’s recognize that when we say “I don’t see your color” you are saying “your color is something I don’t choose to see.” It’s too easy for your listener to hear, “your color is not important,” which can be interpreted as “your identity is not important to me.”

2. Practice using “I statements” as you talk … 

  • about differences, even before you feel fully ready.
  • about your experiences on the advantageous end of white privilege — not from a place of guilt, but from a place of acceptance of the reality — acknowledging how those differences have served us over the generations.
  • about the kind of world you want to live in. If that means one with “liberty and justice for all,” explore ways to see that this becomes the reality we need it to be.

3. Consider how the Mercator map that has been used in our classrooms for decades shows Western, Northern hemisphere (White) bias over Eastern, Southern hemisphere(non White).

(I was tempted to make this into one full post, but I decided to keep these suggestions together). The West Wing (the TV show I’ve been binge-watching the past few weeks) had an episode in its second season that introduced to me The Peters Map. In short, making a flat map from the globe requires choices, which reflect what we think is important. The current Mercator map (current since the mid 1500s) that you’re probably quite familiar with is good for ocean and air navigation, with it’s latitudes and longitudes, but it grossly misconstrues size, a fact which greatly benefits Europe and the northern hemisphere. Here’s that clip from The West Wing, Season 2, Episode 16: Cartographers fro Social Equality. https://youtu.be/OH1bZ0F3zVU    

4. Realize that opportunities to speak out are all around, like…

  • when Colin Kaepernick and others “take a knee” in their protest for racial justice. If we admire their courage, you can say “I think he was quite courageous.”
  • when someone in your social circle or your workplace makes a racist joke. If you find it offensive, if it makes you uncomfortable, you can say, “I find that not only not funny, but offensive as well.”
  • when our implicit bias slants our perceptions. If you want to grow, you can learn to identify your own unconscious biases and admit “I’m open to seeing this in a new way.”
  • when you see how white privilege has given us a ” stay out of jail free” card.  And, if you don’t understand, you can still say, “I don’t understand white privilege. And I want to.”

5. Get educated about what it means to be white in this white society. Start with the list I gave above on white privilege; you don’t have to like the term. Start with the first one — it’s a free PDF file.

You could move on to any number of well done YouTube videos. Here’s one I found last month.

Deconstructing White Privilege: a video Robin DiAngelo, the author of What Does it Mean to Be White? Developing White Racial Literacy is an anti-racist educator.  This 20-minute video is part of the Vital Conversations 1 video series, from the United Methodist Church’s General Commission on Religion and Race. https://youtu.be/h7mzj0cVL0Q

  How about you? What’s still stopping you from talking about race?  Where shall we go from here? What unanswered questions remain? What have I missed?    

17 Responses

  1. Ally Bean
    | Reply

    Interesting as usual, Janet. I like Peggy McIntosh’s definition of privilege because it is applicable to many situations wherein privilege is a way of keeping the other side down– for just being the other side.

    I’ve had one white privilege experience wherein I was given a pass for speeding through a ritzy neighborhood because I was white, while the car immediately in front of me going the same speed but driven by a black woman + family, was stopped. At the time it didn’t dawn on me what was going on, but now I’m wiser to the ways of the police departments. So that’s progress, yes?
    Ally Bean recently posted…Just Curious: Tell Me, What’s Your Least Favorite Holiday?My Profile

    • Janet Givens
      | Reply

      It is indeed, Ally. I used to hold workshops for people who stutter called “Awareness, Acceptance, Change.” That Awareness step is truly the first in so many arenas. Welcome to the conversation. Thanks for starting us off.
      Janet Givens recently posted…Talking About Race: Part III — White to WhiteMy Profile

  2. Janet Heartson
    | Reply

    Janet, this is a thorough and comprehensive resource for anyone who is working toward justice. I am grateful for your work. Very helpful.

  3. Marian Beaman
    | Reply

    If you gathered your Thinking about Race blog posts, you’d have a graduate course on Social Justice 501. Online, of course. Think about it . . . you have credentials! (It could be under-graduate too, the earlier it’s offered the better.)

    Once again, I found your research and the video of cartographers for social equality fascinating.

    But I’m still thinking about “walking barefoot through cooked spaghetti . . . !”
    Marian Beaman recently posted…Aunt Ruthie’s Diary and a London Family VideoMy Profile

  4. susan scott
    | Reply

    Thanks Janet for continuing to widen the conversation. How true this is that when we self righteously say ‘I don’t see colour’ that this effectively also says, your identity is not meaningful to me.

    The what, when, why, where and how …

    I may have said it before so at the risk of repeating myself in a way … I see racism inter alia as a form of scapegoating. It is easier to see the darkness in others (sometimes just the colour of one’s skin is enough to see the darkness in others) than it is to see it within our own selves. It’s such a huge topic. Looking at this issue in a depthful and psychological way goes a meaningful way to addressing the issue. I will check out the links when I can, thank you for providing them. The first time I clicked on Frances Kendall’s link on your post it wasn’t available but I did a google search on her and was able to access it. Still to read.
    susan scott recently posted…#WATWBMy Profile

    • Janet Givens
      | Reply

      Yes, I think Frances Kendall withdrew her free PDF file shortly after I first posted it.

      I agree with the scapegoating view; how easy that is to do in so many areas. I hadn’t thought of racism in terms of a defensive attribution before; it fits well, I think. Scapegoating, blaming, criticizing — all “defensive attributions.” Whenever I catch myself complaining about someone else, I experiment by attributing whatever defect I’m imposing on them onto myself. Rarely does it not teach me something about myself.
      Thanks so much for joining us, Susan.
      Janet Givens recently posted…Talking About Race: Part III — White to WhiteMy Profile

  5. susan
    | Reply

    ‘when we respect our Selves open our hearts and feel our love to each other to the rivers to the mountains to the soil the earth then we enter into a loving grateful creative relationship with all that is’.

    I copied and pasted the above Janet from Sandra’s post – she is in Australia and her blog is the faerie embassy … her 2nd last paragraph is the one I’ve copied.

  6. Laurie Buchanan
    | Reply

    Janet — I never fail to learn something new when I read your blog posts. Thank you. Thank you, too, for providing five suggestions on how to talk about race.
    Laurie Buchanan recently posted…We Witnessed a Murder!My Profile

  7. Tim Fearnside
    | Reply

    Good stuff, Janet. I like to think I’m willing to talk about race, knowing I am both privileged and still have much to learn. One of my first eye-openers was actually in college, when I became good friends with an African American kid about my age during a summer job. This was in the ’80’s, during the height of Reagan’s “war on drugs,” and young black men, in particular, were routinely targeted by the police. My friend, who happened to own a nice sports car, would be routinely pulled over by the police — according to him, almost once a week. This was astounding to me, as I’d never been pulled over in my life except for something I was doing wrong. It would take me longer to fully grasp the concept of white privilege, but this was my first exposure to the idea, and it’s stuck with me all these years.

    • Janet Givens
      | Reply

      Hi Tim. Good story. I’m thinking you were fortunate in a roundabout way to see first hand how differently we are treated based on the color of our skin and how many assumptions and myths get moved to the fore. In the 80s I was rather blissfully unaware of skin color; my focus was on the gutting of federal funding for the arts (via NEA), something we are still paying for today. But I digress. I appreciate you sharing your story. Ever think of looking that old friend up?
      Janet Givens recently posted…Talking About Race: Part III — White to WhiteMy Profile

  8. Pamela Wight (@pamelawight)
    | Reply

    Thanks, Janet. You include so much here! Until I read Jodi Picoult’s novel “Small Great Things” I hadn’t thought of the perspective that as much as I pride myself in not being a racist, perhaps in some ways I am. Why? Because I have white skin, and therefore no idea what it’s like for someone with black skin who is discriminated against because of the color of her skin. I think that I don’t discriminate (and I surely hope I don’t) but just by not putting myself in another’s skin and seeing what she sees, I am racist in some ways. Since college I’ve read many books by/about African Americans (blacks) from their POV, which I’ve felt helped me understand what they go through. But that’s not enough. The least we can do, though, is admit the experience that we don’t understand.
    Pamela Wight (@pamelawight) recently posted…On the Last DayMy Profile

  9. […] … besides being willing to talk about it, that is.  (Please note the subtle reminder to my three-part series, Talking About Race, accessed here). […]

Leave a Reply to From the Middle of Black History Month – Janet Givens Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Have a blog you'd like to share? I use CommentLuv Click here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.